Idol Thoughts…

It seems fashionable these days for “legitimate” music artists to bash <insert country here> Idol and similar reality TV singing contests. Björn Ulvaeus from ABBA is the latest to make his thoughts known.

I guess I can see where the criticism comes from but it is quite a generalisation though. There are some artists who have used the Idol franchise and spun off a reasonable career even if the majority haven’t.  Will Young from the UK has his fourth album coming out in September and Kelly Clarkson from the US is working on her fourth album too.

I think one of the problems is that people need to get it out of their head that it is a talent contest or a singing contest. It isn’t. I’ve always said that with Idol, they take these talented kids and beat the talent out of them.

Many of the Idol viewers are serial reality show watchers. They enjoy picking their favourites and cheering them on and even more, they enjoy picking their villians and booing them whether it’s Idol, Big Brother or whichever reality show it is. There’s nothing wrong with that of course. At the end of the day, it’s a TV show set up for that purpose.

The first clue to Idol not being a credible music contest is that the viewers vote for their favourites. Often this is not based on musical talent. Look how far Jason Castro got in American Idol. He had a couple of good moments throughout the series but clearly had a weak voice with lots of missed notes and pitch problems. What saved him was that viewers warmed to his personality and charming smile. A similar thing happened with Marty Simpson in the last Australian Idol. Viewers liked him as a person and got behind him even though he was clearly not suited to an Idol-type contest.

I realise that success in the music business has never been based on singing talent alone. The ability to interpret a song, own it and then sell it to an audience is just as, if not more, important. Image comes into this as well. But at the end of the day, you have to be able to sing as well.

Another problem is that viewers can vote as many times as they like. The TV show producers are happy with this since it generates a lot of income for them. But there is no way that this can be called a fair contest. In last year’s Australian Idol, there were people on the fan forums proudly boasting that they voted for Natalie 100 times a week (I dread to see their phone bill). Natalie ended up being the winner but quite probably because she got the most number of votes and not the most number of people supporting her. As it was, not many people went out and bought the single and the album. She became the first Australian Idol winner not to have a number 1 single and number 1 album. The album dropped out of the chart like a rock.

I also have major issues with the format of the show. Contestants are forced to sing songs matching a particular theme or style, even if that is not their prefered style. Contestants who dare to be individual or different are criticised since Idol is all about conformity which ends up making it more of a glorified karaoke contest. The problem with a contestant being an individual is that while there may be many viewers who love that, there are also many viewers who hate it. It splits the voting. It is better to be bland and inoffensive. Look how quickly the talented Amanda Overmeyer got kicked out of American Idol. Carl Riseley may have attracted a lot of criticism in last year’s Australian Idol for sticking to his own big band style throughout the series but he did end up with a record contract and a successful album.

My favourite Idol contestant ever would have to be Bobby Flynn from the 2006 Australian series. A very unique talent with a solid music background. Viewers either loved him or hated him because it was very clear what sort of artist he would be. If he had been bland and strictly followed the show’s format, he may have lasted longer but it would have been harder to translate that into a record contract.

This isn’t a criticism of the Idol franchise, more of a reality check (excuse the pun). Idol is a TV show designed to entertain and involve a TV audience and it does that very successfully. However, it is not a music talent contest which will necessarily sell albums. Sure, there may be those who can launch a successful career but they are the exception, not the rule.

7 Responses to “Idol Thoughts…”

  1. 1 Sue
    July 5, 2008 at 7:36 am

    Weak voice ? Not diva belting out doesn’t mean a weak voice. If you prefer a screaming voice, try Syesha or Carly. Maybe those are your music preference. I’ll take Jason Castro acoustic musc over Mariahish any time, at least I can put Jason music on repeat . Anyway to each your own.

  2. 2 rachel
    July 5, 2008 at 7:57 am

    I think you are off in your assessment of Jason Castro. I actually felt he had far less pitch problems on AI than most of the shouters/belters. His appeal wasn’t just his personality (though that does play a part), but people like him because his is a true musician. It’s his passion that makes his music special. And if you don’t believe his musicianship, check out some of the tour videos. He’s been doing a great job and his voice is really coming into his own.

  3. July 5, 2008 at 8:00 am

    I was on Yahoo and found your blog. Read a few of your other posts. Good work. I am looking forward to reading more from you in the future.

    Tom Stanley

  4. 4 JF
    July 5, 2008 at 12:15 pm

    I agree…Idol is not merely a singing competion, or else it would be called (name of country) Singer. But what is truly being sought is an Idol, someone who can “interpret a song, own it and then sell it to an audience”, I too, have issues with the format and the forcing of these kids to fit an irrelevant genre with irrelevant “mentors”.

    Having said that, have you listened to Jason Castro? I mean, closed your eyes and really listened to him sing? Apparently not or you would have heard one of the most original, pure, honest and beautiful voices to come along in a very long time. No, he will never belt out a show tune or rock the house with an Aerosmith cover, and possibly, Idol was not the proper showcase for him. But “a weak voice with lots of missed notes and pitch problems”? Clearly you and I were watching a totally different show! I heard a consistently strong (though not overpowering)voice that was generally pitch perfect! Please find a friend with good taste in music and ask to listen to Jason on his or her iPod…then let us know what you think.

  5. 5 kQQky
    July 5, 2008 at 3:32 pm

    What the he!!?? Why did you feel it necessary to pick out certain contestants by name and trash them??? You could have gotten your point across by using general terms. I read that your are a LIFE COACH and a Telephone counselor?? Wow, I wonder how many of your callers actually felt worse by your petty and catty “counceling”.

  6. 6 twistinthedark
    November 13, 2008 at 11:11 pm

    I was merely expressing my opinions on contestants on a reality TV show which is something people do all the time. I wasn’t counselling anyone and I wasn’t getting personal. In Jason Castro’s case, I did actually acknowledge that he had some good performances.

    I do love acoustic singers but at the same time I do love diva voices too. I have a wide range of musical tastes covering a number of genres.

    Anyway, check out my latest post which is dedicated to Jason Castro. I still stand by my original comments (which is my opinion only) but I hunted down a couple of examples where he was very good so I could give a more balanced view.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s



%d bloggers like this: